Thursday, November 8, 2007

My Mother the Cheerleader by Robert Sharenow

"I've always admired Mr. Steinbeck's writing... However, his account of the Cheerleaders just didn't sit right with me. One passage in particular struck me as being essentially inaccurate.

These were not mothers, not even
women. They were crazy actors, play-
ing to a crazy audience.


My mother was not always a good mother. In fact, she was almost never a good mother. But she was a mother. And she was certainly not always a good woman, but she was a woman--and a human being just like Mr. Steinbeck" (5).

The year is 1960 in the 9th Ward of New Orleans. Thirteen year old Louise is pulled out of school because it is about to be invaded. Her school is William Frantz Elementary and a little first grade girl named Ruby Bridges is marked for the invasion. Despite the city's outcry of protests of this little girl and what she symbolizes, William Frantz Elementary will no longer be segregated.

Louise is just a typical thirteen year old girl. Segregation is not her top priority. She does not see things as black and white. Everything for her is in full color. She rides her bike. She incessantly reads. She plays her own little spy games. She helps out in her mother's boarding house and she longs for her approval and love. Her mother, Pauline, on the other hand, doesn't have time to give her love and approval. She is too busy entertaining her gentleman callers at her boarding house, Rooms on Desire, and protesting with her fellow Cheerleaders against desegregation. She is one of the many who rally and cheer at the school to yell hateful words and throw rotten eggs and tomatoes at that innocent six year old girl. She is also one that looks for attention and love in all the wrong places. Louise, however, wishes that she would use just some of that energy to affectionately rally and cheer in her corner.

As Louise narrates this story, she introduces many colorful characters that come and go from the boarding house. But she takes us on a journey into each of their lives and shows us just how their lives intersect. Each colorful character teaches Louise about compassion, love, and acceptance. But it is through the courage of a boarder named Morgan Miller that Louise and Pauline finally see each other for who they are and for who they want to be.

The story of My Mother the Cheerleader is fiction. But Robert Sharenow added factual and historical elements to create this heartfelt story. But I chose not to give too many details about the Cheerleaders and the wonderful characters that inhabit this story to save the integrity of the story's life-long lessons. This is a story of intolerance, hate, and ignorance. But that is only the symptom of the bigger picture. In many respects, the bigger picture is simply a story about desire.

I think this novel would be a wonderful tool in a high school setting to spark a discussion about how people become so intolerant and hateful. In the end, it's about the path that we take, what we accept into our lives, and what we allow to happen. We become crazy actors in a crazy world. We forget what we truly desire.

5 comments:

Cindy A-L said...

This novel does sound like a great tool for high school. It appears to cover several important themes of our contemporary world. We really need to open our kids eyes up to what has gone on in the past and what is happening today. This book sounds like it could help open up good discussions to do that. I will keep this one in mind for sure. Thanks for your review.

Tom Philion said...

Well-done, Lisa! I especially admire your hyperlinks--they are thoughtful and take me to some interesting commentary and information that expands upon the subject of your book.

So the comment at the start of the review is really from John Steinbeck--is that a real quote (or also something fictional?).

Take care,

Tom

Mirja said...

Nice review. Sounds like it is a really important book.

Just a small, picky little suggestion. You might want to think about repositioning your hyperlink about the school to the firt time you mention the name of the school, not the second.

May said...

Your summary was informative. Sharenow used a catchy title for the book. Using a reading strategy on making a prediction from the title my guest would have been wrong. This type of "historical fiction" would introduce or reinforce events in history.

Janine said...

I almost missed this post. I'm so glad that I found it! You did such a good job Lisa. Your review was very thorough and using the Norman Rockwell painting
Problem We All Live With
not only grabbed my attention but sparked emotion as I immediately thought of the writings and adovacy of Jonathan Kozol.

There were a few times when you looked away from the camera, and more consistent eye contact would have made your review even more engaging. But it WAS engaging to say the least! The elements of your post (text and video) and your expression identified what at first seemed to me to be a not so serious text as a text on a serious subject.

The title of the book made me stop by your post to see what it was all about and your review gives me interest in reading and even adding this book to my collection. Thanks Lisa.